[Spoilers ahead. Also, look for our reviews on blogcritics.com. Coming soon.]
Third episode is tonight (Monday, 10 MAR 08) at its regular time so we better get on the stick, get this posted maybe before episode three starts. We won’t be “live blogging” the whole series but up until Amsterdam meets the potential contemporary The One you might consider all a single episode. We’ll see how it goes.
The second episode of Fox’s new immortality crime show New Amsterdam tightened up in some areas. With two apparently equally balanced plots it’s difficult to assign one as main and one as sub, but it’s a crime show so priority must be assigned to the crime.
A ripped-from-the-headlines murder provides it, in which the killer employs a quite topical, and sometimes fatal, method of self-gratification, somehow in vogue, we’re told, among the young these days, to mask the murder. Although not glorified – lingering on the dying victim may not make the activity attractive to potential self-victims - the smothering was prurient enough for sick types out there to get inspiration from it, especially since it looked like it could have been a young girl.
Second plot-wise, the 400-years-long life-style of our hero, John Amsterdam, crystallizes significantly, when we see that his elderly bartender sidekick is actually a close relation, his son. And this strange relationship is nailed down hard when a flashback also reveals that his elderly secretary back in the Forties had a good reason to keep his secret, since she was his daughter. Both the sidekick and assistant situations may be emphasized or not in future episodes, but now the viewer has this unusual, possibly unique, character trait permanently planted.
This is also the thin thread that ties the one plot to the other, via one line by the distraught father of the victim: “He’s my boy.”
Other than that the whodunit aspects of the crime plot did not jell so well. The murderer had a clear, but somewhat preposterous motive, and the resolution was a deux ex machine provided by a cell phone camera. But the husband of the murderer muddies up the waters some. There was not enough time in the hour to throw in this red herring without deflecting the spine of the story. The whole affair, so to speak, is salvaged by a powerful scene where the girlfriend of the victim speaks at the memorial service and unloads royally on the hypocrites at the school they attended, and fingers, graphically, via images on a large screen, one of the the teachers as the dead boy’s seductress.
Incredibly even this bit was eclipsed by the dramatic tension in the flashback, with the inter-racial love affair between our hero and the past-future mother of the ethnically mixed elderly bartender.
And then from this we were wrenched forcibly into the long-term series arc. Ratcheted up a step here in episode two was John’s search for The One, the woman who the Indian Shaman had predicted would allow him to age, and then die. John is convinced that it’s the doctor who got off the subway and tried to help him when he collapsed, but as both the sidekick and the secretary remind him, John also thought their mothers were The One.
Only reference to any party substances was in the John is shown twice really putting away some scotch . When he’s pouring from a bottle in his office it can be identified as some species of Johnny Walker by the shape of the bottle, but whether black or red label could not be determined. In episode one we saw John at an AA meeting. Looks like the drink will get the better of him at some point.
All in all an interesting and impressively underplayed acting on all parts. Hopefully they have enough episodes in the can to keep it going for a while. According to Media Life Magazine the show’s first episode didn’t do do so well. It won its time slot in a few demographic slices but didn’t reach expectations considering it follows American Idol. And it did even worse on Wednesday. So John Amsterdam may get the death he wishes for. We can only hope he finds The One before the show is cancelled.